Bo Widerberg’s Joe Hill
Viewing a Socialist Icon Through a Libertarian Lens
Joe Hill went down in history as a martyr of the radical labor movement. But Bo Widerberg’s award-winning 1971 film about him, overlooked for decades, tells a different story. Maria Giménez Cavallo and Jo Ann Cavallo show that Widerberg’s Hill is no simple class-struggle hero. He’s a fiercely independent man who fights for free speech, suffers police brutality, and defends himself at a deeply flawed trial against a state set on killing him. The film’s sharpest critique isn’t aimed at capitalism. It’s aimed at government power, and at union comrades who wonder whether Hill is worth more to them as a martyr.
At first glance, it may seem an odd choice to use a libertarian lens to analyze a film about Joe Hill, one of the most recognizable figures associated with the radical labor movement of the early twentieth century, particularly the revolutionary industrial unionism of the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW). His songs and writings made him a celebrated figure among American labor activists, and his execution by the state of Utah in 1915 transformed him into a folk hero of socialist, communist, and labor movements in the decades that followed. Nonetheless, Bo Widerberg’s 1971 Joe Hill1 foregrounds themes consonant with libertarianism—even at times going against the historical record to do so. This countercurrent warrants closer examination, especially since the film was largely forgotten for decades. Despite winning the Cannes Jury Prize and receiving a nomination for the Palme d’Or in 1971, it was virtually unavailable until a restored and remastered version was released in 2015.2
Bo Widerberg (1930–1997) was one of the leading figures in Swedish cinema in the second half of the twentieth century. He deliberately made films in opposition to those of the internationally acclaimed Ingmar Bergman, arguing that Bergman’s intellectual melodramas did not adequately reflect the lives and experiences of ordinary people. Widerberg championed a more socially engaged cinema, portraying individuals from across the social spectrum and often elevating the realities of contemporary Swedish life through lush, sensual cinematography. His fictionalized film about the Swedish-born Joe Hill may appeal to libertarian viewers on several counts, including its implicit depiction of voluntary market exchange, its emphasis on free speech and assembly, its critique of government power, and its almost Rothbardian conception of self-ownership.3 Indeed, for a film that centers on an activist in the IWW, it makes little attempt to explicate the union’s ideology or promote a broader leftist agenda. Instead, it complicates the traditional socialist interpretation of Hill by dramatizing the experiences of an individual who wants to live on his own terms yet finds himself confronted by coercive authority, censorship, and an unjust legal system.
The Promise of Liberty and the Immigrant Experience
Joe Hill opens with a lengthy close-up of the Statue of Liberty, filmed with a handheld camera, underscoring from the outset the ideal of freedom that America promises to its newcomers. The next moment captures the arrival of the Swedish immigrants Joe Hill (born Joel Hägglund, also known as Joseph Hillström) and his brother, inviting the viewer to associate their immigration with the personal freedom and economic opportunity represented by the statue. The symbol recurs in the room the brothers share: Hill even refers to the miniature Statue of Liberty figurine on his desk as he practices his English. The brothers soon part ways: while Hill finds work in a local bar, his brother secures employment in New Jersey.
Widerberg devotes considerable attention to ordinary life in New York City, following Hill’s interactions with the people he meets and gradually turning him into an observer of the society around him. One important encounter is with an Italian-American street urchin, a petty thief with an entrepreneurial spirit.4 When one of the boy’s friends inadvertently smashes Hill’s window while playing ball, the boy stays behind and takes Hill to a glazier, knowing which small business in the area handles this kind of work. After Hill realizes that the boy has stolen his watch and pursues him through the streets, the boy exchanges other stolen goods at a pawnshop in order to return Hill’s property. The camera focuses on each object that the boy puts on the table until the pawnshop owner agrees to the exchange. The scene could be read as a miniature illustration of the Austrian insight that value is subjectively determined by individual actors.5 Hill does not report the boy; instead, the boy becomes a friend and mentor of sorts, guiding him through their immigrant neighborhood. As Hill comes to know the boy, he learns that his thefts support his mother and crippled brother at home.
Hill also meets a young Italian-American woman, Lucia, as they both listen to La traviata from a fire escape of the Metropolitan Opera House. When he asks her whether she can hear better from “up there” (she is a flight above him), she responds “I don’t know what it’s like to hear from down there.” He claims he cannot hear anything from his position and moves to join her. Like his encounter with the boy, his exchange with Lucia suggests seeing—or, in this case, hearing—the world from another person’s vantage point. Both incipient relationships establish Hill’s propensity to cross boundaries and inhabit the perspectives of others, making his later political activism appear less doctrinaire than experiential. Eventually, however, Lucia crosses a boundary of her own—a social one. Despite her attraction to Hill, she accepts an opera singer’s invitation to enter the building, beginning an association that will take her into his world of privilege—leaving Hill outside, both literally and symbolically.
The film temporarily leaves the main character to focus on the “Knitting for the Needy Drive,” in which a group of wealthy women engage in charitable work from the comfort of their homes. It is only when the Italian-American boy steals the group leader’s fur, leading to a chase through the streets, that the woman seems to encounter real hardship firsthand. Through subjective point-of-view shots, we see her look into the eyes of homeless men lying on the street, and her expression becomes increasingly distraught. The scene thus reveals the gap between well-meaning, abstract benevolence toward “the needy” and direct exposure to their lives. A similar movement from secondhand knowledge to witnessed suffering marks the final scene before Hill leaves New York. He stops in his tracks as he sees a middle-aged woman wheeling a large cart carrying an apparently disabled boy and the family’s belongings, while another small boy walks at her side. Since Hill’s young friend was chased by a policeman in the previous scene, the film implies that the boy was arrested and that the family is now being evicted from their home. Like the wealthy woman earlier, Hill is a distraught witness to destitution. Although here he can only look on, later in the film he is quick to take action on behalf of others.
The Independent Hobo
Hill leaves New York City to find his brother, yet when he arrives at his supposed place of employment, he discovers that his brother is no longer there. He takes to the nearby hills, calling out his brother’s name, but he encounters instead a hobo named Blackie. Rather than return to his stable life, Hill joins Blackie on a journey that brings him into contact with people across America living outside conventional social institutions. Blackie soon becomes his companion and mentor, beginning by instructing the well-dressed young man to throw away his suitcase and initiating him into the hobo lifestyle. He even stays behind with Hill until he succeeds in jumping onto a moving train. In the spirit of friendship, Blackie also shows Hill how to steal food when necessary, then shares a stolen chicken with him and other hoboes they encounter in the woods. As the men gather around a fire, exchanging stories and advice over the meal, they form a temporary network of vagabonds. This world of informal cooperation and self-reliance in the open offers an alternative to the urban setting Hill has left behind.
The film imagines Hill’s introduction to the IWW while he is traveling with Blackie. When representatives of the labor union arrive and advocate creating "One Big Union," Widerberg takes the occasion to draw a distinction between the hoboes’ informal voluntary cooperation and organized collective action. In response to the group’s solicitation, Blackie unequivocally rejects the union in favor of his independence, stating: “I’m an independent hobo and I don’t need no organization. I take care of myself and everybody has to do the same.” His statement, in fact, evokes the first rule of the Hobo Code of Ethics: “Decide your own life; don’t let another person run or rule you.”6 The film thus gives voice to a figure who combines self-sufficiency with concern for others, embracing a sense of community based on his own free will rather than on an externally imposed mandate. Hill borrows some of the IWW’s booklets, foreshadowing his later involvement with the union. Nonetheless, the prominence given to this hobo phase of his journey—and the mentorship of Blackie—accords not only with the fact that the historical Joe Hill lived for many years as an itinerant worker, but also with the film’s portrayal of the hobo lifestyle as formative, exposing the protagonist to a culture of independence, mutual aid, and voluntary association.7
At one point, Hill and Blackie are discovered sleeping in a barn. While Blackie runs away and is never seen again, Hill offers to work and convinces the farmer’s daughter to hire him. This arrangement illustrates the market at its most basic level: goods and services exchanged through a mutually beneficial agreement. Hill becomes romantically involved with the woman, and for a time they work together on the farm to support themselves. This apparent bliss and comfort could have lasted indefinitely, but Hill’s wanderlust prompts him to resume his itinerant ways. His decision to leave follows a scene in which he first chases a hobo from the barn and then, regretting his actions, pleads unsuccessfully with him to return so that he can offer him some eggs. Heading back out on the road is thus by choice rather than necessity: he leaves behind both a broken-hearted companion and a steady income. Even after becoming involved with the labor movement, Hill retains the restlessness and strong sense of personal autonomy that characterized his life as a hobo.
Taking Action: From Solidarity to Free Speech to Strike
As Hill travels and takes on odd jobs, he intervenes on behalf of fellow laborers. When he sees that thirsty workers building a road are being sold expensive lemonade by an abusive employer instead of being given water, he opens up a nearby water source for the men to drink. When he later encounters a group of people who had been forcibly removed from their homes during the night and transported by train to the middle of nowhere because they had been on strike, he finds water for them as well, from a nearby tower. These spontaneous actions give way to Hill’s activism as an IWW member in the scenes that follow.
Widerberg imagines Hill taking part in the IWW’s free-speech fights, waged across the country between 1907 and 1916. In the first scene, set in San Diego in 1909, police attempt to prevent Hill and other IWW members from speaking publicly. When Hill asks a policeman why nearby Salvation Army singers are allowed to speak unhindered while his own group is not, he is told that the others are permitted to gather because they are singing. He therefore transforms political speech into music, quickly composing a satirical song that contains the verses “Workingmen of all countries, unite / Side by side we for freedom will fight.”8 In an ensuing scene, the confrontation between IWW activists and the police escalates. This time a group of about fifty men, expecting that they will be too many to be taken into custody, stand on boxes and repeat in succession, “I stand up here today to get back my right to stand up here.” The scene has historical precedents: Frank Tobias Higbie recounts that “knowing they faced arrest, Wobblies sometimes climbed on the soapbox and began reading the Declaration of Independence or the U.S. Constitution to dramatize their point.”9 Yet by foregrounding the principles of free speech and assembly rather than the IWW’s economic agenda, Widerberg allows Hill’s activism to be read from a constitutional and libertarian perspective.
The protest turns darker when police beat the men and throw them into a single overcrowded cell. Their insistence on their “right to a judge” and request for basic sanitary conditions go unheeded. The police subsequently deliver them to unidentified associates, who drag them into the woods and demand they sing the national anthem and kiss the American flag they have been “spitting on.” When the men refuse, retorting that “we don’t spit on flags, we spit on the law,” they are beaten. Rather than sing the national anthem, Hill sings his own song instead—until he is choked breathless with a stick. Ironically, the aggressors are demanding allegiance to a symbol of the US government while brutally beating the men for asserting their rights. This scene, like the protest and jailing that precede it, exposes not the supposed evils of capitalism, but the readiness of governmental agents and their cronies to answer an appeal to constitutional principles with violence aimed at crushing the men’s efforts to organize.
Hill eventually meets up with three IWW activists in Salt Lake City, who appear to be his admiring fans. In one scene, while the three lament the difficulty of persuading waiters to strike for better wages due to the union’s inability to infiltrate the workforce, Hill takes action. Putting on his best clothes, he goes directly to the restaurant most known for exploiting workers and orders a meal. The waiters serve him with a professional demeanor even though they appear confused by his lack of table etiquette, which sets him apart from their regular customers. At the end of the meal, Hill rolls up his sleeves and asks a waiter to direct him to the kitchen. On the surface, he is paying for his meal with his labor rather than cash. In reality, however, he intends to use his time in the kitchen to persuade the workers to go on strike. His ploy succeeds: in the very next scene, the workers are shown on strike outside the restaurant, holding up picket signs.
The Constitution in the Courtroom
The film’s most powerful libertarian dimension emerges when Hill is charged by the State of Utah with killing a grocer and his son. The case against him is deeply flawed: witness testimony is unreliable, identification is uncertain, there is no logical motive, and the prosecution appears willing to manipulate the circumstances to support its argument. Viewers understand that Hill is innocent of the charges not only because of the flimsy case, but also because, shortly before the murder, he unexpectedly ran into his old flame Lucia, presumably accompanying the opera singer on tour. Their subsequent rendezvous remains off-screen, but Hill returns wounded by a gunshot and in need of medical attention. When the doctor later hears about the murder, he mistakenly connects it to Hill’s gunshot wound and alerts the authorities. Police break into Hill’s home as he sleeps and shoot at him before arresting him. He refuses to provide an alibi for his whereabouts at the time of the murder in order to protect the reputation of the woman involved.
At the trial, when the judge tells Hill that he has the right to speak in his own defense, he takes the statement literally. He dismisses his defense attorneys and insists on presenting his own defense, saying, “Who are you to tell me what I mean?” He refuses the amici curiae, saying, “They don’t represent me.” Hill’s refusal of legal representation, invoking his constitutional rights, reflects the agency he has demonstrated at every turn. He then exposes the weaknesses of the prosecution’s case and challenges the reliability of the state’s evidence, even calling attention to the way the police have pressured witnesses to remember events in ways that support the prosecution’s theory. The trial thus becomes a confrontation between the individual and the machinery of the state. The court nonetheless declares him guilty, and the judge sentences him to death—an outcome that makes the injustice even more horrific. This much is clear: the authorities in the State of Utah want Joe Hill dead. No longer merely restricting where Hill can stand or when he can speak, they have claimed the ultimate power over him: deciding whether he lives or dies.
The Death Sentence and the Absurdity of State Power
Not everyone working for the state is portrayed as evil, however. While in prison, Hill develops a friendship with the guard, Harry, who gradually becomes convinced of Hill’s innocence and at one point even offers him the chance to escape. By endowing the guard with a distinct personality and a conscience, the film distinguishes between individual human beings and the institutions within which they operate. Outside the prison, supporters campaign for Hill’s release, with one IWW spokeswoman even reaching President Woodrow Wilson. The Governor of Utah, however, refuses to interfere with the court’s order.
The execution visually illustrates the ultimate expression of state violence against the individual. The multiple shooters are concealed behind a screen, shielded both psychologically and physically from the fact that they are killing another human being. Hill is strapped to a chair and blindfolded, but after hearing a bird sing, he struggles to remove the blindfold. “I want to see” becomes a final expression of his character. Throughout the film, in fact, Hill has tried to see into other people’s lives—especially those of other immigrants, hoboes, laborers, and people living on the margins of society. Now the state attempts to deny him sight as it carries out his execution, even reducing him to an object by placing a paper target over his heart. Hill’s last word is “Fire,” allowing him to give the command himself instead of leaving it to a government agent. He thus dies without surrendering his voice, symbolically reclaiming a final measure of self-determination.
Betrayed by Fellow IWW Activists
The film’s treatment of the three Salt Lake City IWW activists is essential to understanding its skepticism toward the traditional socialist narrative. When, prior to the execution, one of the three remarks to the other two that “the question is—is he more good to us alive. . . or dead?,” he is not considering Joe Hill as an autonomous human being but treating him as a tool to advance union interests. If the state turns him into a legal object—a criminal to be executed—the IWW activists consider him a symbolic object—a potential martyr to be used. In this way, they deny his personhood no less than the state does. Just as painfully, even though one of the activists—Ed Rowan, a historical figure—promises Hill that he and his friends will attend the execution for moral support, in the end no one is present. In his biography of Hill, Franklin Rosemont writes that three “Fellow Workers” from the IWW arrived but were turned away by the warden.10 In the film, however, although Hill voices his suspicion that his friends were not allowed to attend, we see neither the friends nor any evidence that they have been barred, leaving viewers to assume that they simply chose not to come. Widerberg thus makes the ending deeply uncomfortable: although there is widespread support for Joe Hill at all levels of society, key players in the movement that will transform him into a legend fail to support the person behind the myth in his final moments.
The film’s closing sequence likewise imagines a lack of concern for Hill on the part of the IWW representatives in charge of distributing his ashes. While Hill was in prison, he had expressed his final wishes for his body after death in the form of a poem (written by the historical Joe Hill):
My body? Ah, If I could choose,
I would to ashes it reduce,
And let the merry breezes blow
My dust to where some flowers grow.
Perhaps some fading flower then
Would come to life and bloom again.
This is my last and final will.
Good luck to all of you,
Joe Hill
According to historical records, Hill’s ashes—distributed among delegates to the IWW’s 1916 convention and mailed to IWW members throughout the United States and beyond—were indeed scattered to the wind as he had requested.11 In the film’s final scene, by contrast, we see Ed Rowan and two older union representatives placing his ashes in envelopes to be sent to government officials throughout the country as a political message. This disregard of Hill’s last wishes in order to utilize his ashes for their own purposes is not even the most damning aspect of the scene. When the men hear music downstairs, all three carelessly leave the pile of ashes on the table to join in the dancing. The camera follows each of the men sweeping young women across the dance floor, then cuts back to the static image of Hill’s ashes lying abandoned on the table while his voice-over recites his last wishes once more. The stark contrast between the men’s carefree celebration and Hill’s neglected remains is Widerberg’s most direct refusal to let Hill be appropriated by the union into a class-struggle martyrdom narrative. The memorial cards accompanying the ashes complete this revision. Historically, the cards prepared by the IWW stated, in capital letters, “Murdered by the capitalist class.”12 The film’s cards state instead: “Murdered by the authorities in the state of Utah.” The difference is profound.
The Film’s Economics—or Lack Thereof
That substitution—“the authorities in the state of Utah” rather than “the capitalist class” as the entity responsible for Hill’s execution—is consistent with a pattern that runs through the entire film. While Joe Hill stereotypically presents bosses as exploiters, the labor disputes center on securing better working conditions and higher wages, not on any articulated critique of capitalism itself. Widerberg devotes no dialogue and no narrative action to explaining the economic ideas behind the IWW’s revolutionary ideology.13 The closest the film comes to stating the union’s program is a single scrawl on the wall of Hill’s prison cell: “Labor produces all wealth. Wealth must go to labor.” Austrian economists—and libertarians more generally—would, of course, have a field day with that assertion. To begin, it relies on Marx’s discredited labor theory of value; it ignores distinct contributions of capital, land, technology, and, above all, the entrepreneurial function; it treats labor as an undifferentiated mass, whereas any specialized product results from a wide range of contributors, from designers and engineers to distributors and advertisers; and it leaves out voluntary exchange entirely, from the initial contracts right up to the final sale—where the price consumers are willing to pay determines a product’s value and, ultimately, the wealth it generates. Yet the film itself does not ask us to engage with the claim on those terms. Hill never articulates IWW ideology in his own words; he has simply copied a slogan onto his prison wall. This common IWW rallying cry identifies him with the union, just as a map he draws on the floor traces his geographical trajectory.
Widerberg’s own sympathies, in fact, seem to lie some distance from that IWW slogan. His previous film, Ådalen 31, dramatizes the 1931 conflict in which the Swedish military opened fire on striking workers, yet it similarly resists reducing historical events to ideological binaries. Its protagonist, for instance, while on strike himself, protects a strikebreaker from the mob attacking him. The film also humanizes the industrialist, dwelling on his family and eventually showing him condemn the very military intervention he had set in motion. Ådalen 31 focuses on the individuals caught up in the historical events rather than on a political line, maintaining a strong anti-violence stance throughout. Unsurprisingly, the film received negative press from the far left, with one 1969 Swedish critic going so far as to title his review “Widerberg’s Film Lulls Us into Becoming Fascists.”14 Widerberg himself, in the documentary Being Bo Widerberg, critiques the ideological rigidity of the far left through a visually striking metaphor: “People on the far left are often narrow-nosed, so the bones stick out around their noses, and I hate that.”15
Joe Hill: A Sovereign Individual
Reading Joe Hill through a libertarian lens does not require denying the film’s overall sympathetic treatment of the labor movement; it means recognizing that the film’s strongest moral arguments are about individual liberty, in particular, freedom of speech, the abuse of police power, the necessary presumption of innocence, the right to defend oneself, and the danger of allowing the state to impose the death sentence. At the same time, the film virtually ignores the specifics of the IWW’s economic ideology, depicting Hill as a fiercely independent figure rather than the proponent of a collectivist revolution—complicating the traditional socialist interpretation of him in ways that can resonate with libertarians.
Small wonder, then, that in his biography of the historical Joe Hill, Rosemont—an IWW member himself—takes aim at the film, disparaging it as “marred by sentimentality” and “otherwise disappointing in many respects.” Although he does not explicitly identify what most disappointed him, Rosemont continues in a rather heated tone: “Let fiction-writers lie their heads off, and film-directors get their facts wrong.”16 Some reviewers were more explicit in stating their disappointment with the film’s politics. Roger Ebert faulted the film’s supposed “shaky political and moral position.”17 Richard Schickel complained that Widerberg “gives us no idea of [Hill’s] radicalization” and “no idea of the goals of the IWW.”18 A reviewer at the student-run Harvard newspaper called the film “fundamentally wrong in its orientation,” specifying that “Widerberg’s greatest offense stems from his attitude towards the IWW. He tries to ignore them, and when that’s impossible he downplays and perverts their role.”19 Their irritation is a measure of how far Widerberg’s Hill strays from the martyr of socialist memory.
Widerberg’s Joe Hill wanders, works, leaves relationships, rides trains, associates with both hoboes and organized labor, and insists throughout on making his own choices. His greatest enemy is not “capitalism” or even a particular industrialist, but the unchecked power of political institutions that can deny an individual his rights and call the denial law. The final image of Hill’s ashes captures the tension between two forces: the state, which has reduced a human being to a pile of ashes, and a political movement that instrumentalizes his remains. Between the two stands the multifaceted individual Joe Hill, who spent the film trying to see the world from other people’s perspectives and whose final request was simply to be allowed to see. Joe Hill does not ask whether socialism or capitalism is superior. It asks whether any employer, government, or institution may infringe upon the fundamental rights of the individual. As we see it, Widerberg’s answer is a resounding no.
Notes
1. Joe Hill, directed by Bo Widerberg (Bo Widerberg Film / Sagittarius Productions, 1971).
2. Charlotte Pavard, “Cinéma de la Plage – Joe Hill by Bo Widerberg: A Swedish Masterpiece Shot in New York,” May 19, 2015 (https://www.festival-cannes.com/en/2015/cinema-de-la-plage-joe-hill-by-bo-widerberg-a-swedish-masterpiece-shot-in-new-york/).
3. In The Ethics of Liberty, Murray N. Rothbard argues that each individual has an absolute right of ownership over their own body, will, and labor, prior to and independent of the state (Atlantic Highlands, NJ: Humanities Press, 1982). This is the foundational axiom from which the rest of his libertarian property theory (including homesteading and voluntary exchange) is derived.
4. According to Richard Cantillon, who coined the term “entrepreneur” to describe all those who work under conditions of uncertainty rather than for fixed wages, “even beggars and thieves are entrepreneurs in this category” (Essay on the Nature of Trade in General [Éssai sur la nature du commerce en Général, 1755)], translated and edited by Antoin E. Murphy (Indianapolis: Liberty Fund, 2015), 27. We use the term here to capture the boy’s initiative, resourcefulness, and practical knowledge of the neighborhood as an economic structure.
5. Carl Menger (1840–1921), generally regarded as the founder of the Austrian School of economics, developed the theory of subjective value, according to which the value individuals attach to goods depends on their subjective preferences and circumstances rather than on an objective property inherent in the goods themselves. His insights were subsequently developed by Austrian economists, including Ludwig von Mises (1881–1973) and Friedrich Hayek (1899–1992), whose emphasis on subjective value and market coordination stood in fundamental opposition to the Marxist labor theory of value.
6. The Hobo Code of Ethics is said to have been drawn up at the 1889 National Hobo Convention. Although its exact origin is unverifiable, its list of rules constitutes one of the best-known statements associated with American hobo culture. For an online version, see “Hobo Code of Ethics” on the Digital Hobo at https://www.digital-hobo.com/blog/hobo-code-of-ethics.
7. For an overview of historical relations between hoboes and WWI (Wobbly) activists, see Frank Tobias Higbie, Indispensable Outcasts: Hobo Workers and Community in the American Midwest, 1880-1930 (Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 2003), especially chapter 4, “The Hobo, the Wobbly, and the ‘Battle of Mitchell’: Unionization and the Politics of Community in the Wheat Belt,” 134–172.
8. The song is “The Preacher and the Slave,” written by the historical Joe Hill to the tune of the hymn “In the Sweet By-and-By.”
9. Frank Tobias Higbie, Indispensable Outcasts: Hobo Workers and Community in the American Midwest, 1880-1930 (Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 2003), 139.
10. Franklin Rosemont, Joe Hill: The IWW & The Making of a Revolutionary Workingclass Counterculture, intro. David Roediger (Oakland, CA: PM Press, 2015), 137. In addition to Ed Rowan, Rosemont names fellow IWW activists George Child and Fred Ritter. In the film, Hill calls out to all three by first name, only to be met with silence.
11. Franklin Rosemont, Joe Hill: The IWW & The Making of a Revolutionary Workingclass Counterculture, intro. David Roediger (Oakland, CA: PM Press, 2015), 147.
12. Franklin Rosemont, Joe Hill: The IWW & The Making of a Revolutionary Workingclass Counterculture, intro. David Roediger (Oakland, CA: PM Press, 2015), 148.
13. One may get an immediate sense of the IWW’s institutional economic vision from the preamble of its constitution: “The working class and the employing class have nothing in common. [. . .] Between these two classes a struggle must go on until the workers of the world organise as a class, take possession of the means of production, abolish the wage system, and live in harmony with the earth. [. . .] [I]t is the historic mission of the working class to do away with capitalism.” Preamble, Constitution & General Bylaws of the Industrial Workers of the World, 2025 edition as amended through January 1, 2025, organized July 7, 1905. https://www.iww.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/2025-Constitution-ByLaws-and-International-Guiding-Principles-.pdf
14. Jonas Ljungberg, “Widerberg’s Film Lulls Us into Becoming Fascists” (Aftonbladet, May 6, 1969), 5.
15. Being Bo Widerberg [I huvudet på Bo], directed by Jon Asp and Mattias Nohrborg (Sweden: B-Reel Films / TriArt Film / Film i Skåne / Film Stockholm / Sveriges Television, 2025).
16. Franklin Rosemont, Joe Hill: The IWW & The Making of a Revolutionary Workingclass Counterculture, intro. David Roediger (Oakland, CA: PM Press, 2015), 152.
17. Roger Ebert, “Joe Hill,” Chicago Sun-Times, November 26, 1971 (https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/joe-hill-1971).
18. Richard Schickel, “A Pair of Mangled Legends: Joe Hill and Sacco and Vanzetti,”Life, November 26, 1971, 8.
19. Alan Heppel, “Joe Hill at the Cheri 3,” The Harvard Crimson, December 16, 1971 (https://www.thecrimson.com/article/1971/12/16/joe-hill-pbiography-you-say-noonly/).